Menu of Mayday Ice Cream Lakeland in Lakeland, Florida, USA

Menu Overview

Mayday Ice Cream Lakeland is a gem nestled in the heart of Lakeland, FL, where handcrafted ice cream transcends the ordinary into a realm of bold, inventive flavors. The menu is a carefully curated selection that appeals to adventurous palates and classic cravings alike.

One cannot discuss Mayday without highlighting their standout creations such as the Coffee and Doughnut Ice Cream, which masterfully blends rich coffee undertones with a doughnut’s subtle sweetness—a harmony that awakens the senses with each creamy spoonful. The Great Pumpkin Ice Cream taps into seasonal nostalgia, offering warm spices woven intricately through a velvety base, perfect for autumn indulgence.

The Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie is a testament to their artisan craft; it boasts a deep, nutty butter flavor fused with generous chocolate chunks and a chewy cookie texture that balances decadence with comfort. For a taste of something unique, The Aviator combines airy and complex flavors, suggesting a thoughtfully composed profile that invites curiosity.

For those seeking plant-based options, the Vegan Almond Butter Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream stands out—rich, creamy, and fulfilling without compromising on flavor or texture. The Kid’s Cup offers a playful treat of Cookies & Cream Ice Cream with Sprinkles, capturing that timeless joy of childhood indulgence.

Other highlights include the Passion Fruit Flavor Ice Cream on a Waffle Cone, where tropical tartness meets a crisp, buttery cone, and the uniquely nostalgic Blueberry Toast Crunch Ice Cream Pint, which marries fruity freshness with cereal-inspired crunch.

Beyond pints to take home, Mayday’s menu features delightful extras like mochi and cotton candy, enriching the experience with textures and sweetness that contrast and complement their ice cream.

The consistent praise from patrons, such as Courtney Robuck who described her experience as emotionally stirring, affirms the brand’s dedication to fresh, bold, and compelling flavors. Many, including Keri Barona and Tianna West, commend not only the incredible flavors but the warm, knowledgeable service—especially from team members like Emma and Odalys—who elevate the visit from a simple treat to a memorable occasion.

In essence, Mayday Ice Cream Lakeland is more than an ice cream shop. It’s a destination for those who crave creativity, quality, and a touch of whimsy in every scoop. Each flavor tells a story, each bite delivers a carefully balanced experience, and the friendly, welcoming staff ensures that you feel valued—making every visit an indulgence worth repeating.